News

WASHINGTON -- Last week, the U.S. Senate voted to ask the Justice Department to look into what happened in 2005 when Alaska's sole congressman earmarked $10 million in unasked-for money to study a highway interchange in southwest Florida.

The 64 to 28 vote was an unprecedented request on the part of the Senate for a federal inquiry into the actions of a member of the House of Representatives.

At the center of it all: Alaska Rep. Don Young, who acknowledged responsibility last week for the 2005 earmark, which shifted $10 million pledged to help widen Interstate 75 to the interchange study. If built, the interchange promised to benefit one of Young's campaign donors, a family friend whose real estate company owned property nearby. The earmark was one of thousands overseen by Young when he was responsible for pushing a multiyear highway spending bill through Congress.

Young has maintained that there was nothing wrong with what he did, and that the earmark was requested by the community.

But Young is already the subject of a federal investigation, and many questions remain about how the earmark showed up in the spending bill -- after the House and Senate had already voted on an alternative proposal.

What follows is an explanation of where the controversy came from, what's known, and what isn't:

Q. How did the Coconut Road earmark come to national attention?

A. The obscure Coconut Road earmark first came to the attention of transportation planners in Lee County, Fla., in 2006, when they tried to figure out why they had received $10 million in federal money for a study of an intersection that wasn't on their list of transportation priorities.

The transportation board thought it was getting a $10 million earmark to go toward widening of Interstate 75. Instead, the money was earmarked to the study of an interchange that improves freeway access to land owned by real estate developer Daniel Aronoff.

The community was divided over the earmark for the Coconut Road interchange. Although it wasn't on the list of priorities, some organizations, such as Florida Gulf Coast University, had been pushing for the interchange.

Local newspapers, including the Naples Daily News, picked up on the controversy, and posed the question to Young, at the time the chairman of the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee. In 2005, the Alaska Republican oversaw the multiyear transportation bill, a $286.4 billion spending plan for some of the biggest infrastructure projects across the U.S. (The bill also included $452 million for the Gravina Island and Knik Arm spans that came to be known as the bridges-to-nowhere.)

Young refused to address the issue. The story failed to draw national attention until The New York Times wrote about it last spring. The article elaborated on the connections between the developers seeking the earmark and a 2005 campaign fundraiser Young attended in Bonita Springs, Fla., at the invitation of a local congressman, Rep. Connie Mack, R-Fla. (The article also reported that when a Times reporter approached Young to speak to him about it, the congressman "responded with an obscene gesture.")

Those donating money -- about $40,000 total -- to Young included Aronoff, whose family has long been friendly with Young. The earmark for the interchange study showed up not long after the fundraiser.

Q. How was the earmark put in the transportation bill?

A. It wasn't until August 2007 that anyone realized that there may have been an additional impropriety beyond Young's questionable approval of earmarks that benefited his campaign donors.

In Florida, the head of the transportation planning board asked her friend, Darla Letourneau, to research how the county landed the earmark -- and to determine whether there was a way to use the money how they wanted. Both Mack and Young had suggested it might be poor form to turn down the money, and transportation planners wanted to see if there was a way to keep the money but spend it on road widening.

Letourneau, a retired former congressional liaison to the Department of Labor in Washington, found that as the bill was being cleaned up to be sent to the president, the $10 million earmark was given a specific designation for the Coconut Road interchange. Her research showed that the bill was changed after both the House and the Senate voted on it.

The Web site Talking Points Memo took it one step beyond; researchers looked at 6,373 earmarks in the bill and found that the Coconut Road earmark was the only one that underwent any substantive changes.

Q. What was Young's role?

A. Last spring, Young called the matter "a recycled story" and wouldn't answer questions about it. But as ethics watchdogs, journalists and community activists have uncovered more information, his office has been gradually more forthcoming with the sequence of events.

Initially, they would say nothing other than that the community asked for the change in the earmark and that they made it. In December, they told the Daily News that they always intended for the earmark to go to the interchange study. Florida Gulf Coast University asked for it for hurricane evacuation in 2005 when he attended one of their community transportation meetings.

The actual changes to the earmark came during the enrollment process, when transportation committee staffers from both parties (as well as both the House and Senate) sat down with clerks to fix technical problems with the bill. One of Young's aides on the transportation committee made the change at that time.

Last week, Young's spokeswoman Meredith Kenny told the Washington Post that the bill was altered after both the House and Senate voted on it.

"There was an error in the bill and so it was corrected," Kenny told the Post.

But the change was a substantive one that Congress never voted on, and it angered watchdog groups because it was a clear deviation from regular legislative procedure. They have been calling on the House ethics panel to investigate since Letourneau discovered the post-vote change to the earmark.

Their efforts bore fruit last week when Sen. Tom Coburn, R-Okla., a longtime critic of earmarks and wasteful spending, called for an internal investigation by a bipartisan panel of House and Senate members. The panel would help restore integrity to the legislative process by finding out exactly what happened, Coburn said. His proposal failed and the Senate voted on an alternative: a request for the Justice Department to look into criminal activity connected to the earmark change.

Alaska's two senators, Republicans Lisa Murkowski and Ted Stevens, voted for the failed Coburn proposal but not the Justice Department investigation.

Q. What role will the Justice Department have?

A. The Justice Department already has been investigating. A community activist in Florida told the Daily News last year that he had been interviewed by the FBI in 2006. Investigators wanted to know about the political connections of the people who sought the earmark.

Young has been interviewed by the Justice Department and has provided it with documents, his lawyer, John Dowd, told the Daily News. Dowd said he's advised Young not to talk about "matters under investigation." The Justice Department also requested Young not talk about them, Dowd said. The FBI and Justice have several ongoing investigations, including the wide-ranging probe into political corruption in Alaska. They haven't been forthcoming about their ongoing corruption investigations, because of the sensitive nature of investigating political figures.

But Justice also has refused to even address some of the fundamental questions raised by the Senate's call last week for an inquiry into the Coconut Road earmark. It's not clear whether the Justice Department will investigate, or whether it has the authority to look into an internal, procedural matter.

Q. What role did Florida lawmakers play?

A. Young's office has long tried to cast blame on Connie Mack, pointing to a letter he wrote in support of the Coconut Road study. But while Mack was involved in organizing the 2005 fundraiser in Florida, he was a junior congressman on Young's large House committee. Mack didn't have the authority -- or the position -- to actually change the earmark, unlike Young and the staffers he employed on the committee. While he may have asked for the change, ultimately it was Young's staffers who made it. Mack has denied any involvement but also refuses to discuss the matter.

He, as well as other Florida lawmakers (including the ranking Republican on the House Transportation committee, Rep. John Mica) asked for the earmark to go back to its original format: money for the widening of I-75. They were joined in the Senate by both Florida senators, Republican Mel Martinez and Democrat Bill Nelson. Both the senators voted for the Justice Department investigation.

The Senate's request last week for an investigation was actually attached to legislation that does away with the Coconut Road bill and allows Florida transportation planners to use the money as originally intended: for road widening.

Troubles mount for Rep. Don Young

• On Thursday, the U.S. Senate voted 64 to 28 to ask the Justice Department to investigate Young's $10 million Coconut Road earmark.

• Convicted D.C. lobbyist Jack Abramoff's staff had more than 120 contacts with Young's staff over a 25-month period, according to billing records.

• Young refuses to discuss $1.1 million in campaign funds he has spent on legal fees over the past year.



Date Title
4/30/08 Young defends Coconut Road, accuses Mack
4/30/08 Oberstar Anticipates $450 Billion Highway Bill In 2009
4/30/08 Witnesses cite prostitution, other contracting abuses in Iraq
4/30/08 Audit shows $1.6M snafu at WNESU
4/30/08 City councilors seek more travel money, better perks as property taxes set to rise
4/30/08 Cleaning up
4/30/08 Hiring leaps in public sector
4/30/08 Reid pushes breast cancer bill, but can’t defeat minority of one
4/30/08 Young fires back at Parnell
4/30/08 Interior Department Probing Alaska Celebration
4/30/08 GOPer: WTC train will go 'nowhere'
4/29/08 Fairgrounds wins federal grant
4/29/08 New rule allows federal travelers to fly on most European airlines
4/29/08 Council stops interchange dead in its tracks
4/29/08 Clinton: $2.3B in earmarks
4/29/08 Friends of the Earmark Make Themselves Heard
4/29/08 Beach erosion threatens parts of Pawleys Island
4/29/08 Young, Jefferson quiet as Coconut Road earmark nears vote in House
4/28/08 Mower, Mitchell counties shirk State Line Road project
4/28/08 Transportation Chief Peters Backs Congestion Pricing
4/28/08 As Congress retreats on efforts to eliminate baby AIDS, a new study finds few pregnant women with HIV in poorer countries receiving treatment
4/28/08 House Set to Consider Coconut Road Bill on Suspension Calendar
4/28/08 What Does It Mean To Be Alive?
4/28/08 IYRS’ mill rehab attracts $500K in federal aid
4/27/08 Air Force is focus of more contracting probes
4/26/08 Mr. Young Wants Another Road
4/25/08 FAA removes managers in flap over cover-up of air safety errors
4/25/08 Black's lobbying firm billed clients $8.1 million last year
4/25/08 CIETC: Tesdell 'devastated'; Albritton lashes out
4/24/08 Former Metro Official Is Charged With Theft
4/24/08 Lobbyists fight for transpo earmarks
4/24/08 Grant lets teachers learn while on the road
4/24/08 Allard Secures Centennial Project Funding for Rocky Mountain National Park
4/23/08 Young Cries Foul After Senate Calls for Investigation
4/23/08 PI beach erosion continues to worry officials
4/23/08 Next town may break agreement
4/23/08 Federal grants available for public shooting-range projects
4/23/08 Two tracts of forest preserved
4/23/08 Report details Cleburne misuse of funds, criticizes officials
4/23/08 Transport officials say paying cash to bid losers justified
4/22/08 House Speaker Pelosi OK with bill's language on Young
4/22/08 New Climate Change Lab for New Mexico?
4/22/08 Trail expands along Skunk Creek
4/22/08 O.C. dredging project to help beaches and boaters
4/22/08 Destin dredging a drop in the ocean, captains say
4/22/08 Knik Arm bridge: Keep funding?
4/21/08 Brent Batten: Taking off (on) a pair of rants
4/21/08 Here's a reason to eliminate pork barrel projects: veterans
4/21/08 The Road to Somewhere Shady
4/21/08 Current record
4/20/08 DoD travel system glitches won’t be fixed till 2011
4/20/08 Miami Beach Teen club gets $680,000 grant
4/20/08 Monkey love may be in air
4/19/08 Schumer proclaims his support for walkway project
4/18/08 Editorial: NOAA's acquiescing to state stand on fishing aid just makes sense
4/18/08 State takes first step to build new Shishmaref
4/18/08 JSU continues medical school feasibility study
4/18/08 Fishing For Your Tax Dollars
4/17/08 CREW Criticizes Senate Vote Asking for Dept. of Justice Investigation of Coconut Road Earmark
4/17/08 Coconut Road earmark sprouts into full-fledged debate in Congress
4/17/08 Congress May Seek Criminal Probe of Altered Earmark
4/17/08 Earmark Probe Snags Senate
4/16/08 The Coconut Road Affair - How To Investigate A Crooked Earmark
4/16/08 Reid wants DOJ probe of Coconut Rd.
4/16/08 Rivals Back Fla. Earmark Probe
4/16/08 New life for high-speed train from California
4/16/08 Young's legal fees surpass $1 million
4/16/08 CONGRESSMAN: Shays gets earful at Ridgefield meeting
4/16/08 Andrews backs funds for wife's school
4/16/08 Reyes denies donations, contract linked
4/16/08 Money a motivator in I-75 earmark?
4/16/08 Senator wants criminal probe of Young earmark
4/16/08 Tough talk from Washington lawmakers about resolving Coconut Road earmark
4/16/08 Senate divided over response to Florida earmark
4/15/08 Coconut Road earmark investigation gains major momentum in Congress
4/15/08 Florida Lawmakers Dispute Need for $10 Million Earmark for Local Road
4/15/08 Palm Beach Mayor Jack McDonald details highs, lows of coastal challenges
4/15/08 Ex-Director of Smithsonian Latino Center Solicited Gifts and Tickets, Report Says
4/14/08 BHM receives $22M federal grant to buy land
4/14/08 Readers don't like earmarks
4/14/08 Defense Firm Forged Close Ties To Congress to Get No-Bid Contracts
4/14/08 CIETC whistleblower testifies of warnings by agency executives
4/14/08 Probe Puts Spotlight on Earmarks
4/13/08 Landrieu gets BR bike path $1 million
4/13/08 Polygamist sect received taxpayer cash
4/12/08 State, feds on collision course over fishing aid
4/12/08 Welch announces underpass funds
4/11/08 EPA $100K grant to help make nail salons safer for patrons and workers in King County
4/11/08 Federal states Lynchburg can’t repay self for Bluffwalk
4/11/08 Earmarks don't always go for needs back home
4/11/08 Money a motivator in I-75 earmark?
4/11/08 IG investigations save $16B in ’07
4/10/08 City impatient for progress on industrial land
4/10/08 Brewer: DOT plans changes for Cianbro entrance
4/10/08 Should Port Sonoma ferry be part of county’s transportation plan?
4/10/08 Officials: Connector not a priority
4/10/08 U.S. senator wants probe of Coconut Road earmark
4/9/08 Oak Lawn to hire lobbyist
4/9/08 Funding Secured for N-F Train Station
4/9/08 Police chief pursues calm
4/9/08 House Ethics Panel Says Lawmakers Can Become Lobbyists Behind Scenes
4/9/08 Federal Credit Cards Misused
4/9/08 Campus Construction Continues Despite Economy's Woes
4/9/08 Witness discusses Stipe’s brother
4/8/08 Rep. Young's earmarks help his children's employers
4/8/08 Officials feel good about lobby trip
4/8/08 Restoration cost may fall on property owners
4/8/08 Double Duty Dredging
4/8/08 Waterfront progress in Gardiner
4/8/08 Rising travel costs aren’t keeping feds at home
4/7/08 Canal spoils pledged to Sandwich
4/7/08 Lawmakers pad transportation package, but drop Ketchikan bridge money
4/7/08 Coburn Comes Calling
4/7/08 Pork Barrel Remains Hidden in U.S. Budget
4/7/08 Ky. lawmakers finds money for projects
4/6/08 Hurkes, Heilmann feud blows up again
4/6/08 Investigators Review VA Credit Charges
4/6/08 Sand Wars Who owns the sand? Ongoing battle may delay solutions for Plum Island
4/6/08 Flooding D.C. with requests for help
4/5/08 Cash sits unclaimed with state
4/4/08 Palin takes $58 million from lawmakers' projects
4/4/08 Senate GOP earmark plan hits hurdles quickly
4/4/08 Monon Trail extension in early stage
4/4/08 Art center project picks up $400K
4/4/08 Maine leaders trading 'pork' for lobster
4/4/08 Rehberg pushes for more funding for Museum of the Plains Indian
4/4/08 Meet Congress' "King Of Pork"
4/4/08 Dredging to get under way in East Pass
4/4/08 Phony Allocations by City Council Reported
4/3/08 Exactly how much housework does a husband create?
4/3/08 Exactly How Much Housework Does a Husband Create?
4/3/08 City of Aurora restores 1840s house—now it's up for sale
4/3/08 NASA Glenn Research Center's technology transfer program running out of money
4/3/08 Senators decry NOAA's 'fee' from $13.4 million earmark
4/3/08 Feds reimburse Manatee for beach project
4/3/08 Newport Hires a Lobbyist to Secure Dredging Funds
4/2/08 CAGW’s 2008 Pig Book Digs Up $17.2 Billion in Pork
4/2/08 Double Duty
4/2/08 State money allegedly spent on boat, cruise
4/2/08 Six face charges of Medicare fraud
4/1/08 STA lobbies for transportation funds in D.C.
4/1/08 Congress Forgets Ban on Pet Projects
4/1/08 Another FBI Approps Hearing, Another Recusal By Mollohan
4/1/08 Editorial: Lights, no action on Highway 70
4/1/08 Tybee Island Re-nourishment - More Money From Business
4/1/08 Inside The National Debt Control Room
4/1/08 Sidewalks to get makeover
4/1/08 GAO: Weapons systems over budget, overdue, underperforming
4/1/08 Inventor on trial for fraud in his fuel research