News

Sep 30 2006

AIDS bill meets major resistance from Sen. Clinton

Boxer, Feinstein drop objections after assured of funding

Washington -- Over the objections of Bay Area members, the House has passed legislation that would slash the millions of dollars San Francisco gets annually to care for thousands of HIV/AIDS patients.

With the 325-98 vote late Thursday to renew the 16-year-old Ryan White AIDS care program, the focus shifts to the Senate, where a handful of senators from New York and New Jersey were making a last-ditch stand to try to change a proposed new funding formula to preserve money for states that were the early epicenter of cases.

California's two Democratic senators, Barbara Boxer and Dianne Feinstein, dropped their objections, according to the bill's Senate sponsor, Sen. Mike Enzi, R-Wyo., after getting assurances that the state would not be penalized unduly as it switches to operating under new funding formulas. Boxer had been among those who had put a formal hold on the bill.

The chief remaining objector is Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton, D-N.Y., who has attracted a lot of attention for her stand. Her position shows the tension between her two constituencies -- New Yorkers and those across the country she'll need if she runs for president in 2008.

"I am committed to reauthorization of a good bill," Clinton said on the Senate floor Friday afternoon as Congress prepared to leave town until after the Nov. 7 election. "A bill that devastates the ability of high-prevalence communities to deal with cases is unacceptable."

If there is no deal today and Congress leaves, the legislation would wait until a post-election lame-duck session. Sponsors, however, warn that cuts in the program could begin as early as today because money for the continuing program federal money runs out in parts of the country.

San Francisco receives $28 million a year under the current Ryan White program. The House-passed bill would cut $11 million of the amount by the fourth and fifth years of the renewed five-year program.

The city Department of Public Health says such cuts would devastate programs for most of the city's 15,000 HIV-positive residents who are helped under the federal plan.

San Francisco's representatives say the House-passed bill is unfair because it will cut funds for cities that have dealt with the disease since it first surfaced in the 1980s. They also argued that it pits one group of needy patients against others with HIV and AIDS. All the Bay Area's Democratic House members voted against the bill, while Rep. Richard Pombo, R-Tracy, voted for it.

Proponents pointed out that the epidemic has changed over the years, spreading across the country and ethnic groups, moving even into rural areas that might not be getting any federal dollars under the current funding formula. They also point out that the existing program provides money for people diagnosed with AIDS, not just those who are HIV-positive, and that patients are living far longer than they did when the program was created.

"Address the epidemic of today, not yesterday," Enzi told the Senate.

"The House bill is a good approach that takes a little from New York, takes a little from San Francisco, and gives lifesaving drugs to those who don't have them today. We ought to be about doing that today," Sen. Tom Coburn, R-Okla., said on the floor of the Senate.

Clinton and others seeking a revised bill have proposed a one-year extension of the current program to allow time for more negotiations; providing 3.7 percent more than the $12.2 billion authorized for the five-year program; and offering grants for unmet needs in rural areas.

But so far, the talks haven't produced a compromise. Rep. Joe Barton, R-Texas, whose House Energy and Commerce Committee originated the legislation, said the existing House bill already is bipartisan and "makes sure that money is spread more equitably across the country."

Barton warned that many states would face immediate cuts in programs if the Ryan White bill isn't passed by the time Congress leaves for its recess.

But Ernest Hopkins, director of federal affairs for the San Francisco AIDS Foundation, said that isn't true.

"This is all a scare tactic that Sen. Clinton is too smart to fall for. It's a bad bill for her state and others," Hopkins said.



Date Title
9/30/06 Fight Over Earmarks Delays — But Doesn’t Stop — Defense Authorization Bill
9/30/06 AIDS funding bill block stirs party dispute
9/30/06 Current record
9/30/06 Senate passes bill on Iraq and defense programs
9/29/06 Earmarks Find Way Into Spending Bill
9/28/06 Editorial: Ray of sunshine
9/27/06 Pentagon's Troubled Travel System
9/27/06 Bush signs database bill
9/27/06 OMB enlists bloggers' aid in pushing management agenda
9/27/06 GAO questions savings estimates for Defense Travel System
9/27/06 Bush Signs Law Sponsored By Senator Tom Coburn
9/27/06 Coburn's bill on tracking U.S. spending signed
9/27/06 Editorial: Pork defense doesn’t jive
9/27/06 Bush signs bill to create spending database
9/27/06 Report Criticizes Pentagon's New Travel Booking System
9/27/06 Legislation approved for online database
9/26/06 The administration’s new ally on government accountability: Bloggers
9/26/06 GAO: DTS won’t meet savings projections
9/26/06 'RESULTS' of inspection to end contract program at FAA center
9/26/06 Letter to the Editor: Good Job!
9/26/06 Bloggers will join Bush in bill-signing ceremony
9/26/06 Editorial: Antipork Progress
9/25/06 Coburn, Phillips continue quest against earmarks
9/25/06 Inquiry uncovers waste at FAA
9/25/06 Passage of database bill is just the start
9/25/06 Republicans consider loss of majority status
9/22/06 Opinion: Being a Good Citizen Just Got Easier
9/22/06 OMB publishes high-risk list for IT despite misgivings
9/21/06 OMB makes IT projects lists public
9/21/06 Congress Approves Online Database to Track Federal Contracts
9/21/06 Editorial: More transparency, accountability with federal OMB database
9/21/06 Opinion: Bounty offered to get lawmakers to disclose schedules
9/20/06 Editorial: Public's right to know scores victory on Internet
9/20/06 Editorial: Online search through government spending leaves little to hide
9/20/06 Senator says he wants to probe per diem rates
9/20/06 All Set for DDT Use As Ban Lifted
9/19/06 Congress Makes It A Little Easier To Expose Pork-Barrel Spending
9/19/06 Editorial: Online Budget
9/19/06 Editorial: Some good news on reform, but much remains undone
9/19/06 Coburn follows the money on IT
9/19/06 Editorial: Fighting malaria, saving lives
9/19/06 Doctor Tom's DDT Victory
9/18/06 Editorial: Transparency in spending
9/18/06 Opinion: Newbie senators changing D.C.
9/18/06 Senate's 'holds' are secret bill-stoppers
9/15/06 Spending database bill headed to president
9/15/06 OMB says new search tool will reflect accurate spending data
9/15/06 Lawmakers urge limit on 'secret holds'
9/15/06 Agency supports wider use of DDT vs. malaria
9/15/06 WHO Lays Out DDT Strategy, Calling for Its Use Even Indoors
9/15/06 Coburn praised for database bill
9/14/06 OMB sizing up challenge in new spending database
9/14/06 Government Workers on Taxpayer Subsidized Vacations
9/13/06 Editorial: Soon you can follow the pork
9/13/06 House to Hear Measure on Tracking Money
9/13/06 Coburn Says Iraqis Must Do More
9/13/06 Opinion: Secrets in the Senate
9/13/06 Editorial: Soon you can follow the pork
9/13/06 Editorial: Earmark showdown
9/13/06 Iraq 'sobering,' senator says
9/13/06 Coburn Brandishes Replies From Colleges On Earmark Query
9/12/06 Watchdogs Hungrily Eye Spending Database
9/12/06 Watchdogs Hungrily Eye Spending Database
9/12/06 Editorial: Coburn’s bill will allow taxpayers to follow the money
9/12/06 Editorial: Opening a window on waste
9/11/06 Senate approves searchable online budget
9/10/06 Coburn visits Iraq to support fighting, troops
9/9/06 Editorial: Transparency, yes, bring it on
9/9/06 Senate OKs database legislation
9/9/06 McCain says U.S. safer, but still must do more
9/9/06 McCain calls Indian gaming, immigration 'out of control'
9/9/06 Bloggers help Obama pass Senate pork bill
9/8/06 About the Pork Transparency Bill
9/8/06 Coburn's Internet Spending Bill Okayed
9/8/06 Senate approves searchable online budget
9/8/06 Panel examines high-risk technology projects
9/8/06 OMB mulls strengthening IT project oversight
9/8/06 Government Spending Would Get Its Own ‘Google’ Under Senate-Passed Bill
9/8/06 Coburn hoping to change expectations in Congress
9/7/06 Editorial: Bill waylaid by old tradition
9/7/06 Analysis: Health plan merger a red flag?
9/7/06 Editorial: Byrd Forgets Whose Money It Is
9/7/06 Politics as usual with anti-pork bill
9/7/06 Lott Ready To Push Rule Change On Holds
9/7/06 Senate Tradition Trumps Transparency: ‘Secret Holds’ Could Continue
9/7/06 Frist Mobilizes Blogs to Muscle Two of Senate’s Old Bulls on Database Bill
9/7/06 Congress eyes 'pork-barrel' reforms
9/7/06 Senate hold, GOP tension stall transparency measure
9/7/06 'Secret' hold blocks Coburn proposal
9/7/06 Senate wants details on agencies' IT projects
9/7/06 Coalition calls for Senate to act on Coburn bill
9/6/06 Editorial: Playing with your money
9/6/06 Secret block hampers open-government bill
9/5/06 Editorial: Broken 'hold' win for taxpayers
9/3/06 Editorial: Hold off in the Senate
9/2/06 'Pork' traders unmasked as bloggers win Senate battle
9/2/06 Editorial: Time to stop Senate secrets
9/1/06 Congress poised to renew Ryan White Act
9/1/06 Editorial: Caught in the act
9/1/06 Editorial: Don't keep public in dark on pork
9/1/06 Editorial: A political who-held-it
9/1/06 Editorial: Busted by the bloggers
9/1/06 Byrd unapologetic about 'secret hold' on spending bill
9/1/06 Bloggers help smoke out senator over stalled bill