News

A group of five Republican senators is seeking a delay in legislation, supported by several large tech vendors, that would overhaul the U.S. patent system.

The five, including Senators Chuck Grassley of Iowa and Sam Brownback of Kansas, have asked for more hearings before the Senate Judiciary Committee moves ahead with the Patent Reform Act, which is scheduled to be amended and approved in a Thursday hearing. The five sent a letter Monday to the Judiciary Committee asking for more hearings.

"Many prominent American businesses on the cutting edge of innovation are expressing concerns about the impact of sweeping patent reform," said the letter, also signed by Senators Tom Coburn of Oklahoma, Jon Kyl of Arizona and Jeff Sessions of Alabama. "These concerns merit thoughtful deliberation."

Many observers have called the Patent Reform Act the most sweeping reform of U.S. patent laws in decades. The bill would make it tougher for inventors to obtain new patents, make it easier to challenge patents, and reduce the legal penalties for patent violations.

Microsoft Corp., Cisco Systems Inc. and IBM Corp. have praised the bill, saying it's too easy for the owners of questionable patents to sue tech companies and collect large damages or shut down entire product lines with court injunctions when one small piece of a product allegedly infringes a patent.

"This important measure ensures that our patent system continues to foster innovation and economic growth by promoting improvements in patent quality [and] discouraging litigation abuse," Microsoft said in a statement when the bill was introduced.

But five Republican senators raised concerns about the bill, echoed by some small tech companies and other members of the Coalition for 21st Century Patent Reform, a group calling for less sweeping changes to the U.S. patent system.

The senators questioned the bill's attempt to apportion patent award damages. The bill would limit the damages a patent holder can collect when an infringing technology is part of a larger product, based on the value of the patented technology itself, instead of the value of the larger product. Courts now generally consider the value of the larger product when assessing damages.

The senators also questioned the bill's provisions to allow new ways to challenge patents after the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office has granted them.

These changes "need to be more carefully examined to ensure that they do not undermine innovation, increase frivolous litigation, or undermine property rights," the letter said.

The letter also calls on the committee to look harder at ways to improve patent quality.


Date Title
6/29/07 Senate panel passes biogenerics bill
6/27/07 Bill Giving FDA authority to approve Generic Biotech Drugs up before Panel
6/27/07 Senators ready Amendments for Generic Biologics Markup
6/27/07 Senators revive Immigration Bill
6/27/07 Senate Revives a Big Debate
6/27/07 Senate to debate immigration overhaul bill
6/27/07 House GOP Firmly Against Border Bill
6/27/07 Decisive Immigration Votes Lined Up
6/27/07 EPA $100K grant to help make nail salons safer for patrons and workers in King County
6/21/07 Editorial: Not So Sterile
6/21/07 HHS Counters with its own Sex Ed Critique
6/20/07 New Study on Higher Education Spending - Increased State Funding for Higher Education Does Not Positively Impact Economic Growth
6/20/07 Opinion - 'Booty Call': The CDC and your Tax Dollars
6/19/07 HHS Study reveals flaws in Sex Education
6/18/07 Editorial: Centers for Disease Control – Big Spenders
6/18/07 Editorial: CDC focus gone awry
6/16/07 Senator berates CDC for spendthrift tendencies
6/15/07 Editorial: Immigration Laws on the Books
6/15/07 Coburn gathering data on Earmarks
6/14/07 Comprehensive sex education gets failing grade
6/14/07 Study: More ‘condoms’ than ‘abstinence’ in sex-ed
6/14/07 Health Agency Wastes Cash on Consultants, Screens, Report Finds
6/14/07 Opinion - Sen. Tom Coburn: Resolute and Right
6/13/07 Republicans seek delay in Patent Reform Bill
6/13/07 Current record
6/13/07 Senate Panel’s GOP Senators want changes to Patent Bill
6/13/07 Immigration Pitch Falls Short
6/11/07 GOP Pondering Gonzales Strategy
6/11/07 Vote on Gonzales marks Juncture in Probe
6/10/07 Editorial: Lee officials should refuse funds for unwanted study
6/10/07 Commercial Free Speech permits Prescription Drug ads
6/9/07 Passport regulations eased
6/9/07 Death of ‘amnesty’ Bill Hailed
6/9/07 Federal lawmaker takes aim at local immigration issue
6/8/07 Senators approve English-only Amendment
6/8/07 Earmarkist strikes again
6/8/07 No-Confidence Resolution on Gonzales is Scheduled
6/7/07 Campaign Funds for Alaskan; Road Aid to Florida
6/7/07 $10M for I-75 interchange gets national attention
6/7/07 Patent Stakeholders Sound Off To Senate Panel
6/7/07 Work Underway to create open government Web site
6/7/07 Despite Thompson’s Support, Term Limit Movement Lags
6/7/07 Dr. Coburn discusses immigration on CNN's "Lou Dobbs Tonight"
6/7/07 Editorial - Open Checkbook: Tax payers deserve a peek at State Spending
6/6/07 Opinion: Health Care Needs Market Forces
6/6/07 Editorial - Earmark cake and eating it, too
6/5/07 Bill aims to shed light on Business’ tax breaks
6/5/07 Sign tax credit disclosure bill, Henry urged
6/5/07 Republican Senator seeks spending “transparency”
6/5/07 Taxpayer Transparency Act opposed by State Chamber
6/5/07 Puerto Rico’s AIDS Care in Disarray over Funds
6/4/07 Senate GOP Votes Unclear on Gonzales Motion
6/3/07 President’s Push on Immigration tests GOP’s Base