News

Dec 16 2006

Editorial: Inaction plan

GOP shares blame for earmark cuts

REPUBLICANS in Congress failed to finish their work on their major appropriations bills before packing up and heading home — some for good. As a result, millions of dollars worth of special projects in Oklahoma are left wanting because the Democrats who now run the show say they don't plan to revisit those bills.

It would be easy to pop the Democrats for this turn of events, but the Republicans have only themselves to blame. The spending bills were supposed to be taken care of by the first of October, when the GOP still controlled the House and Senate. But only two made it by the deadline and were sent to the president. Democrats, who took control of Congress after the midterm elections, have passed a resolution to keep government operating at current levels until early next year, and that's likely to be extended to next fall.

Our delegation had secured funding for dozens of special projects, or earmarks, and so not getting that funding may lead to delays or even elimination of projects. Sen. Tom Coburn, who has fought earmarks during his two years on the job, said projects in the unfinished bills are "dead from an earmark standpoint,” and that he's OK with the Democrats' decision because of the money that will be saved.

Coburn, R-Muskogee, mentioned to us recently the $11 billion — that's with a B — worth of earmarks included in the recent Defense Department bill in pointing out that earmarks "never get oversight” once the money is appropriated. He said his criteria in separating the spending wheat from the chaff are: Is what's called for in the bill a legitimate role of the federal government? Is it already being done by the state? Does it make sense in a list of priorities?

Some items on the Oklahoma list, such as funding for work on Interstate 40 and on the McClellan-Kerr Navigation System, would seem to pass muster using that formula. Others might not.

That West Virginia Sen. Robert Byrd is one of the members who placed a moratorium on earmarks provides a comic twist, given the truckloads of special-projects money Byrd has delivered to his home state during his long career. That irony aside, there is something to be said for the push by Coburn and others to illuminate these earmarks and subject them to thorough vetting by Congress, even if at times that can be painful.


Date Title
12/28/06 Budget surgery: Painful but necessary; Spending earmarks were a congressional copout.
12/18/06 Opinion: Trimming the fat from pork-barrel politics
12/16/06 Opinion: A thoughtful leader
12/16/06 Current record
12/15/06 Opinion: Earmarks of lamed pork
12/15/06 Editorial: Coburn’s right: Disaster aid bill overblown and ill-advised
12/13/06 Editorial: Their Final Bow
12/13/06 Editorial: Time out for earmarks
12/12/06 Editorial: Farewell flurry
12/11/06 Opinion: Democrats Aren't Ready to Give Up Pork
12/10/06 Opinion: Coburn earns badge of courage
12/9/06 House Nixes Legislation on Pentagon Earmark Disclosures in Landslide Vote
12/9/06 Duncan Native Passes
12/8/06 Members Will Consider Continuing Resolution Today
12/8/06 Coburn: biofuels could benefit farmers
12/8/06 Senator vents on agricultural, Iraqi war, last-minute legislation
12/8/06 Coburn won’t back down on farm bill
12/8/06 Lawmakers question GSA chief's plans for agency auditors
12/8/06 Oklahoma Senator Coburn Battles Pork
12/8/06 Opinion: No Christmas for big spenders
12/8/06 Opinion: Bolton's Gifts
12/8/06 First American female U.N. ambassador, Oklahoman dies
12/8/06 Editorial: Farm aid can wait
12/7/06 Lawmakers demand answers from Doan on proposed IG cut
12/7/06 OCU students hold up signs, photos to encourage support of law
12/6/06 Passage Of MilCon This Week Backed By Senate Conservatives
12/6/06 The Earmark Roller Coaster
12/5/06 Coburn calls not confirming Bolton Senate's
12/5/06 GAO’s Walker wants expanded reporting of improper payments
12/3/06 So Many Bills, So Little Time — Outgoing Senators Face All Kinds of Obstacles
12/3/06 Editorial: Spendthrift: Earmarks will remain target for Coburn