News

Nov 19 2009

Exclusive: Jobs 'Saved or Created' in Congressional Districts That Don't Exist

Human Error Blamed for Crediting New Stimulus Jobs to Nonexistent Places

Here's a stimulus success story: In Arizona's 15th congressional district, 30 jobs have been saved or created with just $761,420 in federal stimulus spending. At least that's what the Web site set up by the Obama administration to track the $787 billion stimulus says.

There's one problem, though: There is no 15th congressional district in Arizona; the state has only eight districts.

And ABC News has found many more entries for projects like this in places that are incorrectly identified.

Late Monday, officials with the Recovery Board created to track the stimulus spending, said the mistakes in crediting nonexistent congressional districts were caused by human error.

"We report what the recipients submit to us," said Ed Pound, Communications Director for the Board.

Pound told ABC News the board receives declarations from the recipients - state governments, federal agencies and universities - of stimulus money about what program is being funded.

"Some recipients clearly don't know what congressional district they live in, so they appear to be just throwing in any number. We expected all along that recipients would make mistakes on their congressional districts, on jobs numbers, on award amounts, and so on. Human beings make mistakes," Pound said.

The issue has raised hackles on Capitol Hill.

Rep. David Obey, D-Wisc, who chairs the powerful House appropriations Committee, issued a paper statement demanding that the recovery.gov Web site be updated.

"The inaccuracies on recovery.gov that have come to light are outrageous and the Administration owes itself, the Congress, and every American a commitment to work night and day to correct the ludicrous mistakes."

ABC News was able to locate several examples on the government's Web site outlining hundreds of millions of dollars spent and jobs created in Congressional districts that have been misidentified.

For example, recovery.gov says $34 million in stimulus money has been spent in Arizona's 86th congressional district in a project for the Navajo Housing authority, which is actually located in the 1st congressional district.

The reporting problems are not limited to Arizona, ABC News found.

In Oklahoma, recovery.gov lists more than $19 million in spending -- and 15 jobs created -- in yet more congressional districts that don't exist.

In Iowa, it shows $10.6 million spent  and 39 jobs created -- in nonexistent districts.

In Connecticut's 42nd district (which also does not exist), the Web site claims 25 jobs created with zero stimulus dollars.

The list of spending and job creation in fictional congressional districts extends to U.S. territories as well.

$68.3 million spent and 72.2 million spent in the 1st congressional district of the U.S. Virgin Islands.

$8.4 million spent and 40.3 jobs created in the 99th congressional district of the U.S. Virgin Islands.

$1.5 million spent and .3 jobs created in the 69th district and $35 million for 142 jobs in the 99th district of the Northern Mariana Islands.

$47.7 million spent and 291 jobs created in Puerto Rico's 99th congressional district.

Stimulus Fund Mystery

Interesting facts and figures, but none of these districts exist.

The recovery.gov Web site was established as part of the stimulus bill "to foster greater accountability and transparency" in the use of the money spent through the stimulus program. The site is a well-funded enterprise; the General Services Administration updated it earlier this year with an $18 million grant.

ABC News' Zach Wolf contributed to this report.



Date Title
11/30/09 IG cites IRS employees for flying first-class
11/30/09 Lawsuit aims to get land for bike trail
11/30/09 Squabbles hold up help for Las Vegas’ homeless
11/30/09 Federal Reserve tries theater ads to burnish its image
11/30/09 Some Arizona stimulus projects draw critics' ire
11/30/09 Following the money - How stimulus jobs are being spent
11/30/09 Old buildings, dwindling rents: GSA faces financial crisis
11/30/09 Most federal screeners to get bigger-than-usual raises
11/20/09 Non-profit's salaries take up much of teacher grant
11/20/09 Review finds fraud in contracts awarded in disabled veterans’ program
11/20/09 Grand Central Terminal for Atlanta?
11/20/09 Hollywood's catered stimulus
11/20/09 Bike commuters will get facilities in parking garages
11/20/09 Grants let orchestra play free concerts
11/20/09 No takers apply for $1.5 million in stimulus funds
11/20/09 Safe Citizens Bingo free to area seniors
11/19/09 Current record
11/19/09 Critics say UN food summit wasteful, ineffective
11/19/09 Stimulus cash will help keep eye on Sunset park
11/19/09 $867K for Montana tribe on hold after state audit
11/19/09 For stimulus funds, unlikely destinations
11/19/09 Improper US government payments hit $98 billion
11/19/09 Researchers ask: Are caged chickens miserable?
11/17/09 FHA reserves fall below legal limit
11/17/09 Border program has vague goals, little oversight
11/17/09 4 years later, R&D company ready to fly
11/17/09 20 percent of Americans hold positive view of government
11/17/09 Report Says Musicians Hear Better Than Non-Musicians
11/17/09 Post office was $3.8 billion in the red last year
11/17/09 Crossing Vineyards adds “green building” – shows what small business can do
11/13/09 Federal deficit sets October record of $176.4B
11/13/09 US expected to lose money from TARP: Auditor
11/13/09 2012: Beginning of the end or why the world won't end?
11/13/09 Ag agencies receive almost $400,000 in grants
11/13/09 When preschoolers ask questions, they want explanations
11/12/09 High School Sports Hall of Fame going up in Pa.
11/12/09 Feds fund preservation of historical city bank records
11/12/09 Study of Acceptance of Evolution Among Muslim Physicians
11/12/09 Despite monitoring, 'dubious' stimulus spending seen
11/12/09 Junket doesn't help kids
11/12/09 TRANSPORTATION: Earmarks favor highway building over bridge repair -- report
11/10/09 Lynch’s wife tied to agencies he won grants for
11/10/09 For the Kraft’s Patriot Place, a golden gateway
11/10/09 Anti-terrorism money going to waste
11/10/09 Las Vegas Boulevard sign-lighting ceremony set for Monday
11/10/09 Behind the Scenes
11/5/09 How does the mind grasp climate change?
11/5/09 Jupiter Inlet Lighthouse celebrates 150 years
11/5/09 Senator: No fed money for US-China wind project
11/5/09 Reports show conflicting number of jobs attributed to stimulus money
11/5/09 Panel goes AWOL in GOP earmark war
11/4/09 Treasury expects debt limit will be hit in Dec.
11/4/09 Wyo. official: Federal stimulus records a 'mess'
11/4/09 STIMULUS WATCH: Salary raise counted as saved job
11/4/09 Not all jobs 'saved' by stimulus were in danger
11/4/09 Poultry giant cuts a deal
11/4/09 S.F. nonprofit may lose stimulus money
11/4/09 Program will monitor Md. doctors' handwashing
11/4/09 Oak Ridge mall project gets $5 million stimulus grant
11/4/09 Ghost lecture today in Palos Heights
11/4/09 Merry-Go-Round Museum hosts operating carousel
11/3/09 Trips to D.C. draining city travel budget
11/3/09 IRS slow reaction to bounced checks costs treasury $20 million
11/3/09 Wichita City buses now equipped with bike racks
11/3/09 New rules for funds generate confusion
11/3/09 Some call stimulus for OKC ferry boats wasteful spending
11/3/09 Board duo query need for ‘bridge to nowhere’
11/3/09 Target 11 Investigates Stimulus Funds
11/3/09 11 Summit projects receive federal funds
11/3/09 Safe Haven Animal Sanctuary wants county's dog control contract
11/3/09 Spay-neuter meeting draws 100 pet owners
11/2/09 Local beauty school receiving $101,080 in Recovery Act funds via Pell Grants
11/2/09 Fox News Poll: Americans Take Congress to Task
11/2/09 Friday's tax-funded presentation
11/2/09 Scant scrutiny, suspect spending
11/2/09 Brewster seeking solar grants for golf
11/2/09 UPS, FedEx reap the benefits of airports' pet projects
11/2/09 Analysis: Airports get $1.1B for pet projects
11/2/09 Bongs and hairballs: Museums you haven’t heard about
11/2/09 Turtles saved by Federal stimulus money