News

The mystery of proliferating holds on a Senate government-transparency bill continued to slow progress on a unanimous consent deal Wednesday, with watchdog groups urging renewed focus on the policy, not the personalities.

Bloggers on both sides of Washington’s partisan chasm called for a halt to Senate blocks on the bill, which would set up a public database of all federal grants and contracts, including those resulting from earmarks. Senate Commerce Committee Chairman Ted Stevens (R-Alaska) and an unnamed Democrat were said to have active holds as of midday, but congressional sources said Stevens removed his late yesterday.

“I’m sure there will be a lot of fingers pointed, but … if the bill becomes law we’re happy,” said Tommy Vietor, spokesman for Sen. Barack Obama (D-Ill.), the bill’s chief sponsor, along with fellow freshman Sen. Tom Coburn (R-Okla.). Their measure landed on the Senate calendar just before the August recess after its voice-vote approval in the Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee.

Yet passage by unanimous consent proved elusive thanks to an unknown number of holds on the bill, triggering a spirited Internet campaign to publicize the objectors.

“From our perspective, it’s a very non-controversial bill, so it’s unfortunate that the shenanigans are tripping up something that is actually good for the country,” said Adam Hughes, federal fiscal policy director at OMB Watch.

An all-star lineup of fiscal watchdogs and budget hawks — OMB Watch, the National Taxpayers Union, the Council for Citizens Against Government Waste, the Sunlight Foundation and the Project on Government Oversight — took to the Capitol on Wednesday to promote the bill, which appeared to be cleared for approval on Tuesday.

Online sleuths, from right-leaning Porkbusters and GOP Progress to left-leaning TPM Muckraker and Wonkette, contacted every Senate office during the recess and eventually discovered two holders: Stevens and Sen. Robert Byrd (D-W.Va.).

But Byrd lifted the hold as he acknowledged it. “The bill should be debated and opened to amendment, and not pushed through without discussion,” the former chief appropriator told bloggers through his spokesman.

The bloggers won a powerful endorsement from Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist (R-Tenn.), who used his Volunteer PAC (VOLPAC) website to ask senators from both parties to cooperate with grassroots inquiries. Frist echoed the watchdogs and Web activists, calling it “deeply ironic” that a plan to remove the cloak of anonymity from earmarks would be blocked by anonymous holds.

Stevens, however, disputes any characterization of his hold as anonymous and replaced his block on the bill late Tuesday, hours after lifting it lifting it for the first time.

“Chairman Stevens has never had a secret hold on this bill, but he told Sen. Coburn he will maintain his hold as long as Coburn maintains his hold on Commerce Committee legislation,” the Alaskan said through his spokesman. Coburn’s office had not been notified of Stevens’ decision to lift his hold by press time.

Though a third Democratic senator has also raised a new objection to the bill, Stevens’ reversal forced Frist to edit another entry quickly on his VOLPAC blog late Tuesday. Beneath a call for the Democrat to lift the hold or “pay the consequences of continued obstruction,” Frist vowed: “Let me be clear, hold or no hold, I will bring this legislation to the floor for a vote in September.”

Stevens originally objected to the cost of establishing a comprehensive OMB database, which the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimates at $15 million over five years. OMB Watch, which soon will launch its own version of the federal-spending catalogue at a cost of $234,000 over three years, questioned the motives of the former Appropriations chairman and famously prolific spender.

“I think [Stevens] could [not] care less how much it costs,” Hughes said. “It’s about the Bridge to Nowhere … about teaching people how it’s done in the Senate.”

Coburn spokesman John Hart denied speculation that Stevens had lifted his hold briefly in exchange for Coburn’s agreement to relinquish his hold on a Commerce Committee bill dealing with estuary protection.

“The reason everyone in America accused Stevens of placing a secret hold is that Stevens refused to answer questions,” Hart said. “If you don’t answer questions from the public, the public gets angry.”

The political points to be scored off Senate gridlock of a good-government bill have attracted Democrats as well as Republicans to the fight. Democratic National Committee Chairman Howard Dean singled Stevens out in an email to party supporters last week.

“A Google-like web site to find out where your tax dollars go — seems like a no-brainer, right? Think again,” Dean wrote, linking to a petition asking Stevens to lift his hold. Dean charged the Senate’s most senior Republican with obscuring “the wasteful mess that he and his party have made of the federal budget.”

Yet the bill’s watchdog supporters point out that the database is unlikely to resemble Google’s format, instead likening it to a receipt for services the government purchases.

Hart said the DNC pitch illustrates the bill’s political value as the midterms approach: “It’s especially harmful to Republicans when you have Howard Dean out there sending fundraising letters on this issue.”

Both Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid’s (D-Nev.) office and OMB, which officially supports the transparency bill, did not return a request for further comment.


Date Title
9/30/06 Fight Over Earmarks Delays — But Doesn’t Stop — Defense Authorization Bill
9/30/06 AIDS funding bill block stirs party dispute
9/30/06 AIDS bill meets major resistance from Sen. Clinton
9/30/06 Senate passes bill on Iraq and defense programs
9/29/06 Earmarks Find Way Into Spending Bill
9/28/06 Editorial: Ray of sunshine
9/27/06 Pentagon's Troubled Travel System
9/27/06 Bush signs database bill
9/27/06 OMB enlists bloggers' aid in pushing management agenda
9/27/06 GAO questions savings estimates for Defense Travel System
9/27/06 Bush Signs Law Sponsored By Senator Tom Coburn
9/27/06 Coburn's bill on tracking U.S. spending signed
9/27/06 Editorial: Pork defense doesn’t jive
9/27/06 Bush signs bill to create spending database
9/27/06 Report Criticizes Pentagon's New Travel Booking System
9/27/06 Legislation approved for online database
9/26/06 The administration’s new ally on government accountability: Bloggers
9/26/06 GAO: DTS won’t meet savings projections
9/26/06 'RESULTS' of inspection to end contract program at FAA center
9/26/06 Letter to the Editor: Good Job!
9/26/06 Bloggers will join Bush in bill-signing ceremony
9/26/06 Editorial: Antipork Progress
9/25/06 Coburn, Phillips continue quest against earmarks
9/25/06 Inquiry uncovers waste at FAA
9/25/06 Passage of database bill is just the start
9/25/06 Republicans consider loss of majority status
9/22/06 Opinion: Being a Good Citizen Just Got Easier
9/22/06 OMB publishes high-risk list for IT despite misgivings
9/21/06 OMB makes IT projects lists public
9/21/06 Congress Approves Online Database to Track Federal Contracts
9/21/06 Editorial: More transparency, accountability with federal OMB database
9/21/06 Opinion: Bounty offered to get lawmakers to disclose schedules
9/20/06 Editorial: Public's right to know scores victory on Internet
9/20/06 Editorial: Online search through government spending leaves little to hide
9/20/06 Senator says he wants to probe per diem rates
9/20/06 All Set for DDT Use As Ban Lifted
9/19/06 Congress Makes It A Little Easier To Expose Pork-Barrel Spending
9/19/06 Editorial: Online Budget
9/19/06 Editorial: Some good news on reform, but much remains undone
9/19/06 Coburn follows the money on IT
9/19/06 Editorial: Fighting malaria, saving lives
9/19/06 Doctor Tom's DDT Victory
9/18/06 Editorial: Transparency in spending
9/18/06 Opinion: Newbie senators changing D.C.
9/18/06 Senate's 'holds' are secret bill-stoppers
9/15/06 Spending database bill headed to president
9/15/06 OMB says new search tool will reflect accurate spending data
9/15/06 Lawmakers urge limit on 'secret holds'
9/15/06 Agency supports wider use of DDT vs. malaria
9/15/06 WHO Lays Out DDT Strategy, Calling for Its Use Even Indoors
9/15/06 Coburn praised for database bill
9/14/06 OMB sizing up challenge in new spending database
9/14/06 Government Workers on Taxpayer Subsidized Vacations
9/13/06 Editorial: Soon you can follow the pork
9/13/06 House to Hear Measure on Tracking Money
9/13/06 Coburn Says Iraqis Must Do More
9/13/06 Opinion: Secrets in the Senate
9/13/06 Editorial: Soon you can follow the pork
9/13/06 Editorial: Earmark showdown
9/13/06 Iraq 'sobering,' senator says
9/13/06 Coburn Brandishes Replies From Colleges On Earmark Query
9/12/06 Watchdogs Hungrily Eye Spending Database
9/12/06 Watchdogs Hungrily Eye Spending Database
9/12/06 Editorial: Coburn’s bill will allow taxpayers to follow the money
9/12/06 Editorial: Opening a window on waste
9/11/06 Senate approves searchable online budget
9/10/06 Coburn visits Iraq to support fighting, troops
9/9/06 Editorial: Transparency, yes, bring it on
9/9/06 Senate OKs database legislation
9/9/06 McCain says U.S. safer, but still must do more
9/9/06 McCain calls Indian gaming, immigration 'out of control'
9/9/06 Bloggers help Obama pass Senate pork bill
9/8/06 About the Pork Transparency Bill
9/8/06 Coburn's Internet Spending Bill Okayed
9/8/06 Senate approves searchable online budget
9/8/06 Panel examines high-risk technology projects
9/8/06 OMB mulls strengthening IT project oversight
9/8/06 Government Spending Would Get Its Own ‘Google’ Under Senate-Passed Bill
9/8/06 Coburn hoping to change expectations in Congress
9/7/06 Editorial: Bill waylaid by old tradition
9/7/06 Analysis: Health plan merger a red flag?
9/7/06 Editorial: Byrd Forgets Whose Money It Is
9/7/06 Politics as usual with anti-pork bill
9/7/06 Lott Ready To Push Rule Change On Holds
9/7/06 Senate Tradition Trumps Transparency: ‘Secret Holds’ Could Continue
9/7/06 Frist Mobilizes Blogs to Muscle Two of Senate’s Old Bulls on Database Bill
9/7/06 Congress eyes 'pork-barrel' reforms
9/7/06 Current record
9/7/06 'Secret' hold blocks Coburn proposal
9/7/06 Senate wants details on agencies' IT projects
9/7/06 Coalition calls for Senate to act on Coburn bill
9/6/06 Editorial: Playing with your money
9/6/06 Secret block hampers open-government bill
9/5/06 Editorial: Broken 'hold' win for taxpayers
9/3/06 Editorial: Hold off in the Senate
9/2/06 'Pork' traders unmasked as bloggers win Senate battle
9/2/06 Editorial: Time to stop Senate secrets
9/1/06 Congress poised to renew Ryan White Act
9/1/06 Editorial: Caught in the act
9/1/06 Editorial: Don't keep public in dark on pork
9/1/06 Editorial: A political who-held-it
9/1/06 Editorial: Busted by the bloggers
9/1/06 Byrd unapologetic about 'secret hold' on spending bill
9/1/06 Bloggers help smoke out senator over stalled bill