Right Now

Jun 17 2013

McCaskill, Coburn Seek Support from Colleagues on Revision to Health Care Law

As support for the bipartisan measure grows, Senators circulate letters to gain additional support

WASHINGTON – U.S. Senators Claire McCaskill (D-Mo.) and Tom Coburn (R-Okla.) are continuing their bipartisan effort to change a problematic provision in the Affordable Care Act, sending a letter to their Senate colleagues, urging them to join the 23 current cosponsors of the Hospital Payment Fairness Act of 2013.

“We’ve made progress with this legislation—but I won’t quit building support until it becomes law and this provision is removed,” said McCaskill, a strong supporter of the 2010 health care reform law. “Whether or not you represent one of the 40 states who currently lose money due to this loophole, we should all want a system that’s designed fairly.”

“This revision will end an earmark inserted in the law that primarily benefits one state at the expense of others,” Dr. Coburn said. “I look forward to more of our colleagues joining us to sunset this unfair provision.”

Medicare rules stipulate that a state's urban hospitals must be reimbursed for wages paid to doctors and staff at least as much as rural hospitals. The Affordable Care Act required that Medicare reimbursements for hospital wages come from a national pool of money, instead of from each state's allocation. As a result, any increase for one particular state means a decrease for other states. As Dr. Donald Berwick, President Obama’s former nominee to oversee the Medicare program, has acknowledged: “It’s a zero sum game. What Massachusetts gets comes from everybody else.”

This new provision proved problematic since Massachusetts has only one rural hospital—Nantucket Cottage—which sets the floor for wage reimbursements in the state. While rural hospitals typically have lower wages than urban ones, wages at Nantucket Cottage are high because of the hospital's remote location and high cost of living. Therefore, the rural wage floor established on Nantucket has become a boon for hospitals in the rest of Massachusetts. Nantucket Cottage's rural designation has allowed the state's 81 other hospitals to collectively reap hundreds of millions of dollars in Medicare reimbursements at the expense of other states.

“The current wage index, on net, benefits only nine states, while 40 see a negative impact from the provision,” the letter reads.

Earlier this year, the U.S. Senate approved a bipartisan amendment to the Senate Budget Resolution on this issue by a margin of two-to-one. In March, McCaskill and Coburn joined together to ask for the support of the American Hospital Association “which declined to support the measure”

The National Rural Health Association and 20 state hospital associations have previously expressed concern with the current provision of law. Earlier this year they wrote the President about the “adverse impact” Section 3141 of PPACA is having. They noted this provision of law “permitted the Commonwealth of Massachusetts to manipulate the federal Medicare program, reaping an estimated $367 million annually from the other 49 states—and unfairly favoring one state’s hospitals and Medicare beneficiaries to the detriment of others.” The association warned that “if left uncorrected, hospitals in 49 states will experience reduced funding of more than $3.5 billion over the next ten years as a direct result of this manipulation.”

McCaskill and Coburn’s amendment provides a pathway for the elimination of that provision in the Affordable Care Act, meaning states like Massachusetts would be responsible for bearing the burden of their own increased rural wage floor costs, instead of draining reimbursements meant for other states.

Copies of McCaskill and Coburn’s letters are available online, HERE and HERE.


Date Title
6/27/13 Dr. Coburn’s Statement on Passage of Senate Immigration Bill
6/27/13 Bipartisan Group of Senators Forge Student Loan Compromise
6/27/13 Dr. Coburn’s Statement on DOMA Ruling
6/27/13 Senators Reject Department of Interior’s Federal Hydraulic Fracturing Regulation with Introduction of FRESH Act
6/27/13 Senators Manchin, Burr, Coburn, Alexander, King Introduce Bipartisan Permanent Student Loan Solution
6/26/13 The Obama Administration’s Decision Terminates the Insure Oklahoma Program
6/26/13 Senators Coburn, McCain, Ayotte Ask that the U.S. Department of the Air Force Meet Their NDAA Deadline in Letter to Acting Secretary Fanning
6/21/13 Senators Request GAO Probe CO-OP Projects Under Health Reform Law
6/21/13 Senators Question Tavenner on Effectiveness of New Innovation Center
6/20/13 Senators Express Concerns With Navigator Proposed Regulation in Letter to Secretary Sebelius
6/20/13 Coburn and McCaskill Introduce Bipartisan Legislation to Means-Test Medicare Premiums
6/20/13 Sequester This: Coburn Finds Little Evidence of Sequester Diet at USDA as Agency Binges on Spending
6/20/13 Dr. Coburn Offers Amendments to Immigration Bill
6/19/13 Senators Klobuchar, Toomey, Shaheen, and Coburn Request That The GAO Examine Price Transparency for Medicare Beneficiaries
6/19/13 Coburn Asks Treasury To Stop Making Excuses and Release Conference Spending
6/18/13 Boxer, Coburn Praise Senate Passage of the Hope Act
6/17/13 Current record
6/14/13 Examining Medicare Spending: What’s Realistic to Expect?
6/13/13 By The Numbers: Entitlements Drive Spending
6/13/13 Washington's Leadership Crisis
6/13/13 Sequester This: Dr. Coburn Urges DOJ to Stop Crying Wolf on Sequester and Address Abundance of Wasteful Spending
6/10/13 Senators Carper, Coburn and Congressmen Roskam, Carney Lead Bipartisan Effort to Combat Billions of Dollars in Waste, Fraud and Abuse in Medicare and Medicaid
6/6/13 Bipartisan Senate Coin Legislation Offers Taxpayer Savings, Deficit Reduction
6/6/13 GAO Report Highlights Defense Department’s Failure to Curb Improper Payments
6/6/13 Senators Introduce Bipartisan Legislation to Reduce Overlapping Benefit Payments
6/5/13 Dr. Coburn Asks Why IRS Conferences Were Omitted in Previous Treasury Response
6/5/13 Dr. Coburn Asks VA to Clarify Policy on Employees Paid to do Union Work While Veterans Face Backlog
6/3/13 Chairman Carper, Ranking Member Coburn Highlight Release of Federal Program Inventory
6/1/13 TEST